SEO audit: what a real one should show you.
A real SEO audit shows where your business stands in Google today and what it will take to move. In writing and dated, it lists your main searches with Google’s own position for each, which pages are indexed, which page answers each search, where you show on the map, and the work each fix involves.
Written by a company that sells Ottawa SEO services, where the audit is the second step of every plan. Every quote below is Google’s, so check us against the sources at the bottom.
On this page
What an SEO audit is
An SEO audit is a written diagnosis of why your site does or does not show up in Google, and what to fix first. Google’s page on hiring an SEO sets the test: an audit “should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved.”
It is the before picture, not the monthly work that follows it. Most audits cover three parts:
- Technical. Can Google reach, read and index your pages. Google's own list of what an SEO might advise on names “hosting, redirects, error pages, use of JavaScript”.
- On the page. What each page is about, its title, and which search it is meant to answer.
- Local. Your Google Business Profile and the map results, which for a service business in Ottawa or Gatineau are often where the calls come from.
An audit can also be padded with findings Google says do not matter, such as a missing keywords meta tag. Our guide on how to choose an SEO company lists the usual padding, so you can strike it out before you price the work.
What a useful audit shows you
Six findings, each written down with a date, so month three has something to be measured against.
1. Your main searches, and Google’s position for each
The starting point is Google’s own numbers, from Search Console: every search your site appeared for, with its clicks, impressions and average position. Search Console defines that position as the “topmost position occupied by a link to your property”, averaged across searches. It is Google’s figure, not a tool’s estimate.
A useful audit picks the five to ten searches that bring paying work, a painter’s “interior painting kanata” rather than the business name, and writes down where each one stands on a named date.
2. Which pages Google has indexed
A page Google has not indexed cannot rank. For a site under 500 pages, Google’s Page indexing help says you probably do not need the full report: search for your domain and the exact address of each key page instead, and use the URL Inspection tool for one page’s status.
The same help page says “Don’t expect every URL on your site to be indexed.” So the audit should name the unindexed pages that matter, and why each one is out.
3. Which page answers each search
Two of your own pages chasing one search leave Google guessing. We found it on our own site: on 2026-08-27 Search Console showed four pages of velogics.ca, the home page, the contact page and two service pages, for the same four searches. Their titles ended in the same kind of promise.
We replaced the titles on two of the four that day, so each says what only it offers. An audit should name one page for each search that pays, and flag every other page competing for it.
4. Where you show on the map
For a local service, the map results often carry the calls. Google says local results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity”, and that prominence draws on “how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have.”
So the audit reads the Business Profile itself, checks where it shows from several parts of your service area rather than from your office, and counts the reviews on the weakest business in the map results. Our guide on why a business is not showing on Google Maps shows how to take that reading yourself.
5. Speed from real visitors, and whether leads are counted
Search Console’s Core Web Vitals report is based on “real world usage data”. A small site often reads “No data available” there, because there are too few visits to report, and then a lab test such as PageSpeed Insights is the fallback, read as an estimate.
Then check the site counts what matters. On 2026-09-04 we checked seven Google Analytics properties we look after, ours included. On five, the master switch for enhanced measurement was off while every setting under it read on.
On velogics.ca, two lead events had been marked as key events since 2026-07-29 with no code on the site sending either. An audit that never sends the contact form or taps the phone number cannot tell you which work brought a lead.
6. The work each fix involves
Last, Google’s own test. Each finding should say what fixing it involves and who does it: a weak title is one edit, while a site with no page for its main service needs that page written. What an audit should never give you is a promised position. Google is plain about it: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.”
Why a tool’s score is not a ranking
Free audit tools give a site a score out of 100. That number is the tool’s own checklist, not Google’s view. Google’s page on hiring an SEO says third-party tools “don’t have access to Google’s internal ranking data”.
A score cannot see the businesses ahead of you, their reviews, or how far your customer is from your address. So a site can score well and still sit off page one for the search that pays. Before you change anything a tool flags, Google says to check it “against official guidance from Google Search”.
The position in Search Console is the number that follows your ranking. Searching your own name from your own office is the weakest reading of all, for the reasons our Maps guide sets out.
How to get an SEO audit done
Google’s advice for a small local business is that “you can probably do much of the work yourself”, and most of an audit is free if you use Google’s own tools.
The free version, in an evening
- Open Google Search Console for your domain and export the Performance report for the last three months: each search, its clicks, impressions and average position.
- Search site:yourdomain.ca, then the exact address of your home page and each service page, to check that Google has them indexed.
- For each search that brings paying work, note which of your pages shows. Two pages for one search is a finding.
- On a phone, signed out, search your main service from two or three parts of your service area, and count the reviews on the weakest business in the map results.
- Open the Core Web Vitals report. If it says “No data available”, run PageSpeed Insights on the home page and one service page.
- Send yourself a message through your own contact form and tap your own phone number, then confirm both show up in your analytics.
If you have someone else do it
Give read-only access. Google says to “only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don’t grant them write access)”. Ask for the findings in writing and dated, with your searches and positions listed, and the work each fix involves.
Then ask who will make the changes. A recommendation changes nothing in Google until it is on the live site, and an audit handed to someone who cannot edit the site stays a document.
The best time for one is before a redesign. Google names a site redesign as a good time to bring in an SEO, “the earlier, the better”, so the new site is designed to be “search engine-friendly from the bottom up.”
What our own audits found
An audit earns its keep by finding things that were not obvious. Two from our own sites, with the dates we found them.
On 2026-08-27 Search Console showed four pages of velogics.ca, the home page, the contact page and two service pages, appearing for the same four searches. Their titles all ended in the same kind of promise, so Google had nothing to tell them apart. The fix was one page for each search, with titles that say different things.
On 2026-09-04 we checked seven Google Analytics properties we look after, ours included. On five, the master switch for enhanced measurement was off while every setting under it read on. One site showed 918 page views in 30 days and not one scroll, click or form start. The settings page said everything was on; only opening the reports showed what had stopped counting.
Three more, with what we did about each, are on our common SEO mistakes list.
Where Velogics fits
The audit is step two of our process, after a free scoping call: where you rank right now, what is broken technically, and the state of your Google Business Profile, written down so month one has something to be measured against. Trades will find the same written baseline on our page about SEO for contractors.
Whether you hire an SEO consultant or a company to run the audit, ask for the baseline in writing. Ours comes with SEO in Ottawa.
It is part of our SEO + AI Agents + Care plan, $388 CAD a month as our pricing page showed on 2026-11-19, with hosting and the AI front desk inside that figure, on a 12-month term, billed monthly. The same plan covers a site we did not build.
The people who host and fix the site do the work, so a finding becomes a change that week, not a ticket for someone else. Each monthly report re-reads the searches the audit wrote down.
To talk it through, phone +1 (613) 383-5521 and our AI receptionist will find a time.
Questions people ask next about SEO audits.
What is included in an SEO audit?
Three parts: technical (can Google reach and index the pages), on the page (which search each page answers) and local (the Business Profile and the map results). The finished document should list your main searches with Google's own position for each on a named date, which pages are indexed, which page answers each search, where you show on the map, and what fixing each finding involves.
How do I audit my website for free?
Use Google's own tools. Search Console is free and gives you every search you appeared for, with clicks and average position. A site: search shows which pages Google has indexed, and PageSpeed Insights tests speed. For the map, search your main service on a phone from a few parts of your service area. The six steps are in the section above on how to get an SEO audit done.
Can ChatGPT do an SEO audit?
It can read what you give it: a page's text, its title, an export from Search Console. It does not have your Search Console data or Google's view of your site unless you hand it over.
Google's advice for any tool's audit applies: check the recommendations “against official guidance from Google Search” before making significant changes. Use it to explain a finding, not to decide what is true about your business.
What should an SEO report include after the audit?
The same searches the audit wrote down, measured the same way each month, with the change since the baseline. Then a list of what was changed on the site and the profile that month, and what did not move. Our guide on how to choose an SEO company covers what a report hiding those searches behind a score looks like.
How often should a business get an SEO audit?
A full audit at the start, and again before a redesign or a move to a new domain. Google names a redesign as a good time to bring in an SEO, “the earlier, the better”. Between those, a monthly report that re-reads the audit's searches shows whether the fixes are working.
What is technical SEO?
The part of SEO about whether Google can find, read and index your pages, as opposed to what the pages say. Google's page on hiring an SEO lists it as technical advice on “hosting, redirects, error pages, use of JavaScript”. Speed sits here too: Search Console's Core Web Vitals report reads it from real visitors.
Where this comes from
Every quote was read on its publisher's page on 2026-11-16. Google updates its help pages, so check the current wording before you rely on a detail. The two findings about velogics.ca are from audits of our own site. Nothing here is drawn from any client's account.
- Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
Read 2026-11-16, last updated 2026-06-05. Quoted for what an audit should give you, read-only Search Console access, third-party tools, checking a tool's audit against Google's guidance, ranking guarantees, the redesign timing, the small local business sentence and the list of technical advice.
- Search Console Help: What are impressions, position, and clicks?
Read 2026-11-16. Average position is the topmost position of a link to your site, averaged across the searches it appeared in.
- Search Console Help: Page indexing report
Read 2026-11-16. Under 500 pages, use site: searches and the URL Inspection tool; “Don't expect every URL on your site to be indexed.”
- Search Console Help: Core Web Vitals report
Read 2026-11-16. The report uses real world usage data, shows “No data available” when there is not enough, and points to PageSpeed Insights for a live test.
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google
Read 2026-11-16. Local results rest on relevance, distance and prominence; prominence draws on links to the business and how many reviews it has.
Our own pages
- Our SEO page: the mistakes we found on velogics.ca, and our four steps
/seo-ottawa, read 2026-11-16. The 2026-08-27 Search Console finding and the 2026-09-04 analytics finding are audits of our own site, published there with their dates.
- Our pricing page
/pricing, read 2026-11-19: the SEO + AI Agents + Care plan at $388 CAD a month, hosting and the AI front desk included, on a 12-month term, billed monthly, and that the same plans cover a site we did not build.
Free scoping call